The four-month-old grandchild of soccer coach the former Manchester United defender lost his life after being placed in an “unsafe sleeping position” on his stomach by an unregulated maternity nurse, an inquest heard.
Madison Bruce Smith was found unresponsive by his dad, ex-Leeds United striker his father Matt Smith, at the family residence in the Trafford area last year.
Smith and his wife, Amy Bruce, had employed the maternity nurse via Ruthie Maternity Services under the impression she was skilled, trained and vetted and that the firm was well established. Both the individual and the service were subject to formal regulation.
Coroner's Findings
In a narrative conclusion at Stockport Coroner's Court, the coroner stated “his cause of death could not be ascertained” after he was “placed in a prone and unsafe sleeping position”.
The presiding coroner for the region the coroner issued a prevention of future deaths report to the Health Secretary urging statutory oversight.
Events Leading to the Incident
The inquest heard Clements was employed after the baby had suffered difficulties with afternoon naps.
The head of the maternity service, head of Ruthie Maternity Services, said she had no formal medical training and possessed only a first aid certificate and a Level 2 diploma in postnatal care gained from a short course and a lengthy project.
The maternity nurse said she had a university degree in early years education but conceded she had no medical qualifications.
“I hope the services can be regulated and, in the future, parents are not left in a position where they believe they are employing someone who is qualified to guide them when they are evidently not qualified,” the coroner said.
The inquest heard Madison's parents would “never have dreamed” of putting their son asleep in the prone position but for the recommendation of the maternity nurse, who was said to have informed them all four of her own babies had slept on their stomachs with no problems.
Such advice was contrary to recognised safe sleeping guidance from the National Health Service and health professionals for young babies.
‘Illusion of Qualification’
The coroner added the “purported expertise” of individuals without proper training posed a significant danger to all children where those services without oversight were used.
She continued: “The evidence shows that practically speaking any of us as while the term ‘registered nurse is tightly regulated, the term ‘nurse’ is not. This creates an illusion of someone who is well-trained and capable of supporting new parents.”
‘Perfect Little Boy’
She said Clements had been sleeping in another room and had the duty of checking on the baby but, although he was heard through a baby monitor to move several times during the night and had been crying, she had failed to go into his nursery.
Madison's parents, together with Bruce, who was most recently manager of Blackpool Football Club, and his son, ex-footballer Alex Bruce, attended the hearing.
Ex-Manchester United defender Bruce was managing Blackpool at the time of the incident and missed the club's next match. In a message posted, he had said: “It's been the worst time of my family’s life and is something no family should have to endure.”
In a testimony presented in court, Smith said the couple's son was their “cherished, perfect baby boy”.
He said: “The loss of our son has been utterly excruciating. The pain is beyond words and often overwhelming. It has completely broken our entire family.”
He added: “We believe that Madison died in a complete regulatory vacuum. Without regulation this will happen again and other parents will place trust in people who are not fit to be in the care of newborn babies.”
Criminal Investigation
The coroner's court was informed the agency provided training on one-day courses for a cost of £450.
The agency head told the coroner that those she trained were given the safe sleeping advice to put babies on their backs to sleep.
However, the nurse said she had been instructed by her to put babies in a prone position.
She rejected telling Madison's mother she was a nurse and also denied suggestions she had “convinced her” the prone position was appropriate.
The court heard authorities conducted an investigation and detained the maternity nurse on suspicion of child neglect.
Det Ch Insp the senior investigating officer, of the police force, said the Crown Prosecution Service was approached for advice, and it was determined that the criminal threshold had not been reached.
He said this was primarily due to the unregulation of such maternity services and that it was not illegal to place a baby on its front.
He added it could not be determined that Clements set out to wilfully harm Madison.